In its decision in the case of Çatal v. Turkey (application
no. 2873/17) the European Court of Human Rights has unanimously declared the
application inadmissible. The decision is final. The case concerns the
dismissal of a judge by the Supreme Council of Judges, pursuant to a legislative
decree adopted during the state of emergency, as one of a number of measures
taken after the attempted coup d’État. The Court
has rejected Ms Çatal’s application, finding that she did not exhaust domestic remedies. The Court observed in particular that a new remedy was available to Ms Çatal, provided for in Legislative Decree no. 6851 , enabling her to challenge her dismissal before the Supreme Administrative Court (judicial review).
has rejected Ms Çatal’s application, finding that she did not exhaust domestic remedies. The Court observed in particular that a new remedy was available to Ms Çatal, provided for in Legislative Decree no. 6851 , enabling her to challenge her dismissal before the Supreme Administrative Court (judicial review).
The Supreme
Administrative Court’s decision could then, where applicable, be challenged
before the Constitutional Court (individual application). Following an
application to the Constitutional Court and a ruling by that court, anyone
could, if necessary, lodge with the European Court of Human Rights a complaint
based on the Convention. Legislative Decree no. 685 had therefore put an end to
the dispute as to whether the domestic courts had jurisdiction to judicially
review the measures taken by the Supreme Council of Judges.
The Court also
stated that its conclusion did not in any way prejudice a possible
re-examination of the question of the effectiveness of the remedy in question,
and particularly the ability of the national courts to establish consistent
case-law compatible with the Convention requirements. It stressed, moreover,
that it retained its ultimate power of scrutiny of any complaint submitted by
applicants who, in accordance with the principle of subsidiarity, had exhausted
the available domestic remedies. (hudoc.echr.coe.int)
Σχόλια